Monday, February 11, 2008

Why we fight

All over this land there are groups of local people giving up time and energy to defend something, a place, a building or community resource from being swept away. The motives for removal usually arrive draped in language of crushing mediocrity:

"We (?) must not stop [stand in the way of] progress ..."

"There will be job opportunities ..."

These campaigners frequently are said to be 'nimbys'; as representing a 'vested interest' – something no one could accuse developers of having.

Well, here is my riposte: I took these today and are they not glorious? Proud to be stopping progress, nimby to the core!

(Normal service will be resumed soon when I have some more correspondence to put up concerning the suspended 2002 plans for 'developing' the paint factory for offices and gifting the nearby open space to the developer for car parking.)

Sun in winter




Sunday, February 3, 2008

Stasi HQ ...

The deeply unlovely Shieldfield Health Centre on Portland Road.


(With apologies to the fine people who deliver health care to the community at Shieldfield ... But they make you work in a simply horrible building!)

A letter from the Council 17 April 2002

My impulse (slow off the mark I admit) to create this blog was a series of letters exchanged in the first part of 2002. I had some telephone conversations with the Council officer concerned (civilised) and the local MP's agent (patronising). Then the political situation changed and the in-coming Liberal Democrat Council appears not to have pursued the 'scheme'.

I have re-typed the first letter I received from the then Council, partly because of the problems of scanning and clarity and also to delete the name of the Council officer; this blog is about issues not personalities and I do not wish to be seen to being in pursuit of anyone. There are greater matters at stake.

Deep breath ... I am NOT against development and indeed I am much more of a 'developer' than I may appear. In my view the whole area between the Ouseburn road and rail bridges and Shieldfield would benefit from large scale re-development where possible, especially the 70s vintage flats and the adjacent Shieldfield Health Centre, which face onto the open space. It is simply the type of re-development and its uses. The potential is exciting, but the plans that have been proposed are (or were) full of an aching familiarity and short term thinking. The character of the area was ignored, possibly because developers think the same way where ever they happen to be. Not so much planning as paperhanging. Newcastle, once described as a world class example of Georgian and Victorian architecture, has suffered enormously at the hands of developers in recent decades. Even now, buildings are going up which are not even trivial.


Some points from the letter are made in notes which I have added immediately beneath the text.

Dear Sir/Madam (sic)

17 April 2002

Dear Sir/Madam (sic)

DRAFT DEVELOPMENT BRIEF FOR LAND AT PORTLAND ROAD

The Draft Strategy for the Regeneration of the Ouseburn Valley identified the former Paint Factory site on Portland Road as a development opportunity where there was strong developer interest for a Business Park. Unfortunately that proposal was not forthcoming. (1) However, although the site has not been marketed (2), there has been interest in the site from a number of developers and guidance in the form of a Development Brief is viewed as essential.

The Brief once it is approved by the City Council will set out the relevant planning policies contained in the Unitary Development Plan (UDP) and other considerations to be taken into account in developing the site. At this stage it is in draft form and is going through a public consultation process. (3)

The Draft Brief suggests that the site should be developed for business/light industrial (4) but as part of a mixed use scheme including a broad mix of housing type, density and size but clear that student accommodation would not be an appropriate use. (5)

The Draft Brief proposes that there may be scope to utilise parts of the adjacent City Stadium open space as part of a larger scheme subject to agreed improvements to the existing leisure and recreational facilities, retaining the cycle route and enhancing the recreational/habitat quality of the open space. (6) It suggests no more than 10% of the City Stadium will be made available to be incorporated into a scheme.

....

Yours faithfully



My notes (3rd February 2008)

(1) 'Strong' has changed its meaning.

(2) i.e. Sold off to private developers.

(3) At this time I had been involved in another 'public consultation process' in another part of the city. It was a remarkably sinister experience of Nixonian duplicity and bad faith.

(4) The use of 'suggests' and 'should' in the same sentence is noteworthy.

(5) There was an underline emphasis in the original letter. It was noticeable at this time how quick the spectre of 'students' was rolled out to cover the tracks of naked greed developers and 'buy to let' rent racketeers. One would never have guessed that by 2002 Newcastle benefited by some 350 million pounds per annum (at 2002 prices) from the presence in the city of 40,000 students. By some accounts they were the saviours of the 'corner shop' in some areas.

6. Put simply this is 'planning gain' whereby, in return for the gift of 'public open space' any 'preferred' developer would have to provide some 'recreational facilities'. Maintenance, the year on year costs to keep such facilities up to scratch, would of course, be a charge on the Council Tax payers. In my reply (See below) I pointed out that if 10% were to be granted (i.e. given away) then thereafter a precedent would have been created and further slices (in fact the whole open space) could be up for grabs. This is precisely what the developer envisaged in a three tier scheme in which the first was a 'modest' acquisition of land for car parking (1300 cars!) and the third a complete take over of the site for a flash sporting club (no doubt fee paying). Greed was their down fall and nothing more was heard of this scheme – but this does not mean the idea is dead.