Saturday, February 16, 2008

An exchange of views ...

As promised I am publishing here the correspondence I had with Newcastle City Council over plans to 'take in' a large slice of the City Stadium next to the former paint factory (demolished) in Battlefield. The plan as promoted (jointly I now understand between owners and the Council) envisaged building a car park for thirteen hundred vehicles over 'part' of the City Stadium site – effectively 'taking in' the whole site eventually for development. The gain accruing thereby to the City Council and local people was not clear; that to the developers only too apparent.

This threat has not in my view 'gone away' (though it may not be as immanent). Plans such as these have a habit of returning and it is noteworthy that no new proposal has come along since this scheme was placed before the public. A change in the political control of the City Council (Liberal Democrats ousted Labour meantime), is no guarantee of a secure future for the open space I chose to call (appropriately in the circumstances) 'Battlefield'.

Firstly, a letter written by Jim Cousins, MP. This is a copy of a letter to then (and as now) Labour Member of Parliament for Newcastle Central, Jim Cousins to the Newcastle City Council official in charge of the development of the former paint factory site, including the construction of a large car park over the City Stadium open space (sic). This letter was copied to me by Mr Cousins as a matter of courtesy. I have deleted the name and telephone number of the Newcastle City Council official for previously stated reasons; I am not concerned with individuals simply principle. Mr Cousins is in the public eye and that is a different matter.


24th May 2002

...
Head of Planning and Transportation
Enterprise, Environment & Culture Directorate
Civic Centre
Newcastle upon Tyne
NE18PH


Dear ...

Former Paint Factory site, Portland Road, Sandyford (sic)

A number of constituents have contacted me regarding the future use of the former Paint Factory site at Portland Road. I would be grateful if you could let me know what the current situation is regarding this site and its proposed development. It would be helpful if you could provide me with as much detail as possible about the planned use of this site and the nature of any proposed development.

This is clearly an extremely important site in the ongoing development of the Ouseburn Valley. I should stress that my constituents are extremely supportive of such development, as long as that development is both appropriate and in keeping with the needs of the community.

Yours sincerely


Jim Cousins


A developers board over the former Reg Vardy car showrooms. September 2007. This site has been cleared and will be developed for offices. It is adjacent to the former paint factory. Newcastle has several older office blocks unlet and some new provision as yet unlet. Office blocks are frequently built purely for investment and taxation gain.




View of the former paint factory. September 2007.

Further more ...

6 June 2002

Jim Cousins MP
21 Portland Terrace
Newcastle upon Tyne
NE2 1QQ

Dear Mr Cousins

FORMER PAINT FACTORY SITE, PORTLAND ROAD, SANDYFORD

I refer to your letter of 24 May regarding the above site.

The current position is that a draft brief for the site was approved by the Council's Development Control Committee on 5 April 2002 for public consultation and a copy is attached for your information. Consultation with Local Councillors, property owners and occupiers in the area and other interested parties is now in progress and a number of responses have been received. The intention is to revise the brief in the light of comments received and report the final version to Development Control Committee on 28 June for approval.

Once the brief is approved the Council has informally agreed with co-owners Akso-Nobel that the site will be jointly marketed and, via a selection process, a preferred developer will be selected to undertake the redevelopment of the site. I agree that it is a key gateway site to the Lower Ouseburn Valley and can confirm that the marketing particulars and eventual scheme selection criteria will reflex this view.

If you have any comments to make on the brief I would be pleased to receive them before 14 June if possible.


Yours sincerely


(name deleted)

Head of Planning and Transportation

Take a letter ...

Finally (for the moment) a letter to me about the last state of play in the game of development musical chairs. Incidentally, a letter from me to the developers architects was NEVER acknowledged. (NB Italics used in this copy are my emphasis.)


(NCC official's details deleted.)

6 September 2002

(Contact information deleted.)

Dear –

DEVELOPMENT BRIEF – LAND AT PORTLAND ROAD(1)

Thank you for your letter commenting on the Draft Brief for land at Portland Road.

The final version of the Brief was reported to the 9th August 2002 Development Control Committee where it was approved.(2) Your comments, along with all the comments received as a result of the consultation process, were reported to the Committee prior to a decision being made. Technical amendments requested by the Environment Agency and Cycling Touring Club have been included in the Brief.

The main revision to the final approval brief relates to the proposal in the draft version identifying the possibility of the development encroaching onto the City Stadium open space to generate investment.(3) However it was noted from the consultation responses that there were clear objections to this idea. Instead it has been agreed that a Management Plan be prepared and implemented for the City Stadium including identifying alternative sources of funding to bring this area of open space up to a level that will meet the aspirations of the community.(4) Accordingly the idea of allowing some limited development of the open space has been removed from the Brief.

I hope the above is of assistance. Should you require any further information please contact me on (deleted).

Yours sincerely


(Name and signature)
Planning Officer

1. As previously pointed out the Council refer throughout to the site as 'Portland Road'. This should be seen as being the closest major road rather than an exact location.

2. That is, despite objections to the fundamental ideas behind the Plan aka 'Draft' (that public open space could be built over by private developers for private gain) it was approved largely unaltered. This should be seen in the light of the constant refrain that 'consultation' is always being sought; they listen then ignore you.

3. Open space is only public when it cannot turn a penny. As soon as the chance comes along it can be cashed in for short term profit. (Please do not bore me with the old 'we need the jobs' arguments. I have seen a lot of this version of 'job creation' in my time and it simply never happens or quickly drops away.)

4. This is pious tripe. I have been involved with or on the edge of several 'consultations' and they were a sham. It may be hoped that one day the term will revert to its original and honoured meaning. Meanwhile be on your guard.
A view of the former paint factory site (to left of photograph). September 2007.